What's the best tent for winter camping? I'm interested in a two- to three-person tent that's lightweight, packable, and available at a low price. I will be spending time in northern Massachusetts and the White Mountains this winter. I've been looking into single-pole shelters like the Black Diamond Betamid ($98), and while comfortable with not having a sealed floor, I worry about water seeping in. Do these tarps really work? Are they reliable? Is it possible to find a reliable four-season tent under $200?
— Boaz Sender Boston, Massachusetts
Got your own gear question?
Express yourself in the Gear Forum
Well, it all depends on how much shelter you really want. Single-pole tarp/tent hybrids such as the Betamid offer the advantage of lower weight (it tips the scales at a mere 2 pounds, 2 ounces) in return for a single-wall, non-breathable design, and of course, no floor. In the right hands, a Betamid can be set up in the snow to make a sort of semi-igloo, and can be a perfectly adequate winter tent. You'll need to pack along some sort of tarp for a floor, however (well, that's optional, but I think it would be useful), and even at that you'll find that snow and moisture can find a variety of ways to creep in. You'd certainly survive, and might not even miss the sealed floor. Then again, you could end up wet, cold, and miserable.
On the other hand, I'm not sure how much better you'll do in the sub-$200 tent market. Not a lot out there in the four-season realm, particularly if you want to house as many as three people. Probably your best option is Eureka's Alpenlite 2XT, which is a bona fide all-weather tent for a mere $200. It weighs a very impressively light six pounds, but it's a little small —- adequate for two people, impossible for three. From there the price tag ramps up pretty quickly. Walrus's Starstreme SE ($279), although technically a three-season tent, would manage well in the winter and can sleep three if need be. And there's REI's Convert Mountain ($249), a well-designed little tent with a sort of tunnel entrance that helps keep out blowing snow. It's primarily for two people, however. So there are a few choices, at least. My advice is to ditch the third member of the party, and get the Alpenlite.
Readers' Mailbag: The Gear Guy digs into some of your more bizarre, obscure (and let’s face it, downright weird) posts from years gone by to see if he can make sense of it all, or if it’s just time to run up the white flag. Previous column: Beat the Cost of Gear.
The Gear Guy reports from the 2005 Outdoor Retailer summer trade fair, with his rundown of ten products to watch in 2006, plus the inside scoop on what shook down at the bi-annual gearapalooza.
Well, it all depends on how much shelter you really want. Single-pole tarp/tent hybrids such as the Betamid offer the advantage of lower weight (it tips the scales at a mere 2 pounds, 2 ounces) in return for a single-wall, non-breathable design, and of course, no floor. In the right hands, a Betamid can be set up in the snow to make a sort of semi-igloo, and can be a perfectly adequate winter tent. You'll need to pack along some sort of tarp for a floor, however (well, that's optional, but I think it would be useful), and even at that you'll find that snow and moisture can find a variety of ways to creep in. You'd certainly survive, and might not even miss the sealed floor. Then again, you could end up wet, cold, and miserable. 
