Subscribe to Outside Magazine
advertisement
Survival Guru

Today's Question
What should you do if you run into a cougar in the backcountry? answer

What is the number one backcountry skill people should learn? answer

Eco Adventurer

Today's Question
What are the five best environmental movies of all time? answer

What are the greenest colleges? answer

Videos Ask Dave
  • What kind of dog will make me look manlier? answer
  • Is there a sport that safely combines my twin passions for guns and kayaks? answer
  • How come most of the world's cultures enjoy eating goat, but Americans don't? answer

Online Favorites

Special Issues

Photo Galleries


Survival Guru

May 01, 2009 RSS


Survival Guru Question
Survival Guru Tony Nester
Survival Guru Tony Nester
In the movie Rambo, Sly heats up a metal rod and uses it to cauterize a bullet wound. Is this effective?

— LCPL Michael Barnes
Camp Pendleton, California



Survival Guru Answer

Ah, where would the survival industry be without Rambo and his magical knife? This is another example of what I call the TBH (Trained By Hollywood) effect that many of us succumb to. Much of what is passed to viewers of television shows and movies—as it relates to survival—doesn’t translate to the real world.

So, to answer your question: No, it is not effective. You are essentially sealing in any bacteria and crud. I know, "The Romans and Apaches did it," you say. But they also allowed for a huge attrition rate in their warriors from combat-related mortality and "improvised" medicine."

Do you have a question of your
own?


Ask a Question Here

I even ran this question by a colleague of mine who teaches for the Wilderness Medicine Institute of NOLS. He said that Johnny Rambo, with his Special Forces background, should have known better and kept the wound clean with frequent changes of gauze and antiseptics (most likely herbal meds gathered under wilderness conditions). Not exactly the vein-bulging, face-contorting scene a producer is looking to include.



 Subscribe to Outside and get a FREE Gift!
 Give the gift of Outside Magazine!
 Subscribe to Outside Online's free weekly e-mail newsletter featuring gear reviews, fitness advice, galleries, podcasts, and more.


RECENT QUESTIONS
Got a question for The Survival Guru? Ask it here.
•  What should you do if you run into a cougar in the backcountry?
•  What is the number one backcountry skill people should learn?
•  What's the number one reason people get lost in the backcountry?
•  How should you deal with a bite from a Southwest scorpion?
•  What is the most abundant and evenly distributed edible plant in the United States?
•  What is the best way to treat stream water if you get lost and have no purifier?
•  What should you do if your boat sinks in the ocean and there is no floating debris?
•  Can you practice or train for dealing with pain in a survival situation?
•  What is the best gear to bring with on a desert hike?
•  Can you recommend a survival class on edible plants?


RECENT FEATURES
•  Survival Stories: The Good, The Bad, and the Just Plain Lucky
•  I Will Survive: The Top Wilderness Survival Stories
•  Into the Wild



Survival Guru
Tony Nester is the founder and director of Ancient Pathways, a wilderness skills company specializing in desert survival and primitive technology. With 18 years of survival training under his belt, Nester has instructed the U.S. Military, National Park Service, and actors, including Emile Hirsch for his role in Into the Wild. He is the author of three books and teaches a number of survival courses throughout the year.